top of page
Search

Just The Way It Is: The IGF, Generative AI, and the Crunch We Award

Writer: Matthew Dyet
Matthew Dyet
Nov 11
6 min read

On the 10th of November 2026, a group of IGF jurors shared a statement indicating that they would not vote for any game that made use of generative AI in any capacity. Following this statement, House House - developers of Untitled Goose Game and Big Walk, released their own statement explaining that they had used generative AI in the final months of development on Big Walk to resolve an issue in their game, requiring only a few lines of code. This usage would not meet the standards set out by the IGF jurors, and that's fine - House House has already done exceptionally well with the release of their game, and have made it clear that they respect the process enough to be honest about their AI usage.


Singling out generative AI creates a key question: Do the IGF jurors look at the output, or the output and the process that created it? And if the jurors do look at the process, why have other unethical practices like systemic crunch not made their way into the criteria of judging?


Generative AI isn't the problem, it's the symptom. The root cause is our constant push for games to be bigger, smoother, better - no matter what the cost. We push for our games to be this way because, well, surprise, it's capitalism. But if we focus on the problems within our control (short of an uprising of the working class) then the thing we have some control over is our culture as an industry. Developers did (and still do) reach for crunch to make these things happen. Our businesses and players are content with us working unhealthy hours to make more in less time. As an industry we tend to create longer games with better graphics by people who are paid less to work more.


Like crunch, generative AI is a thing that developers reach for when they cannot easily solve a big problem. Much of the conversation online has suggested House House should have hired a disposable contractor to fix the problem instead. This just perpetuates the unlivable working conditions and instability currently experienced by developers. It trades one harm for another: a single task, no job security, the same instability that creates crunch in the first place.


Generative AI is also itself a symptom of the capitalist system we live in. Our phones are built on cheap labour, cheap shoes and clothes imported from countries with few protections for workers, animals shoved into cages for the mass production of meat products. Recognising that there is no ethical consumption under capitalism isn't an argument for using generative AI: it's about understanding that the issue is the whole system, not the choice of an individual to use the tools the system provides. If we want to discourage use of AI, punitive action will only encourage duplicity. We need to instead celebrate and elevate the high standards we want to see, so that others aspire to those standards.


This is then a question about what we value as a community of game developers. We should value art in the face of a tool that was built by pilfering human knowledge, which has fundamentally damaged our ability or willingness to share that same knowledge. But I believe that the reason generative AI particularly matters to the games industry is because of the visible impact it has had on our industry and on the artform. The ethical issues that are less visible to us are also easier to ignore. So let's bring them out into the light.


IGF applicants declare their AI usage, so why shouldn't they also declare the conditions in which their game was developed?


In their statement, the IGF jurors elaborate that their goal is "to state solidarity with those who despair over the future of their art, their craft, and their industry". I count myself among those people, but not purely because of AI usage. It's because of the mass layoffs of talent for the gain of capital, it's because of the abuse of workers at mismanaged studios to meet deadlines, it's because of the enshittification of our products to keep players hooked and spending a little bit longer.


The statement from the jurors is forward facing, looking to prevent the impacts of AI on our industry as it is not a foregone conclusion. But I do not believe that should stop us from taking meaningful action against those entrenched problems that currently pervade our industry. Shine the light on the whole thing then, not just the current focus of our collective ire. People might lie. They'll lie about AI usage, too. The point is to make people think critically about what goes into making their games and elevate the truly exceptional, not just the ones who didn't use AI but may still have harmed their teams.


Development conditions impact the final product just as much as (if not more than) the usage of generative AI. If our intention is to improve the future of the craft, make IGF submissions declare their development conditions alongside their AI usage. These are both elements of the process, which does expand the scope of what is being judged. But it's already been established that jurors are comfortable with that. If the intent is to improve the art, judging needs to expand to the process to hold games to a higher ethical standard. We need to look at the whole picture of the context in which a game was made, not just whether a singular tool was used.


The uncomfortable truth I think is that it is easy to single out AI and not our development practices because our development practices are not currently in question: it's just the way it is. And this is reflected in the jurors' statement, pushing back on what is deemed inevitable and being concerned with the future of the art. Unethical development practices are the status quo in the games industry, generative AI is not, so the argument is to resist it before it becomes so. This ignores and undermines the very real damage our industry has done and continues to do to its most talented individuals, because that's a present problem rather than a future one. So is the argument to make the industry a truly better place to be, or to resist the change that potentially makes it worse?

If we are concerned about the future of the art, the craft, and the industry, then that means acting on present and past problems, and not just potential ones.


I believe the IGF jurors have two options moving forward. They may either judge games on their merits as art, regardless of how they were made; or expand the role of the juror into making decisions not only about the merits of the art but also the conditions in which it was made, and whether the process meets the ethical standard we want to encourage in our industry. It seems to me that it would be unfair to rule out usage of a singular tool based on concerns about its ethics without examining the whole process, or even the ethics of the other tools used in it. I would hope a game made in the equivalent of a sweatshop would be held to the same set of ethical standards. The implication at present is that as long as it did not use AI, it will be fine.


If we are truly to move forward as an industry we need to interrogate our development practices and not just the use of a single tool in it. We (game developers) perpetuate our own ethical problems, and generative AI just happens to be one that has broken in from outside. Whether they are big studios or small teams, our industry is full of examples of poor treatment of labor spoken only in secret. Stories that go untold in public because they are often uncomfortable truths that potentially damage the careers and livelihoods of people in the communities built around these businesses. If we want to see real positive change in our industry and our games, we need to push these stories to the surface. We need to face those uncomfortable realities of the culture we've created around ourselves as an industry.


We are in desperate need of leadership and action on the systemic issues facing our art as an industry. This is a missed opportunity to treat generative AI usage for what it is: a symptom of the constant push in our industry for more, better, faster, and cheaper. If we want to truly see positive change and push for our industry and its labor to be treated fairly in future, that starts with holding people to a higher ethical standard across the whole process, not just in a single part of it. Real, positive change for those despairing over the future of their industry won't come from a punitive ban on AI, but it might if we choose to elevate the kind of standard we want to see in our games and the teams that make them.


If you found this even a little bit insightful, I really recommend reading Brendan Keogh's thoughts on the subject.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Joy of Figuring Shit Out

Modern games have been having a crisis of trust with their players. Yellow paint (for its excessive hate) is a great example of how this often comes through in the way we make our games. Level designe

 
 
 

Comments


WebsiteBookends_HeaderT.png
  • BlueskyPaddedWhite
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • ItchIoPaddedWhite
  • Instagram

© 2025 Matthew Dyet. All rights reserved.
The content, design, code, and graphics on GreatGames.dev are the intellectual property of Matthew Dyet and are protected under international copyright laws. No part of this website may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form without prior written permission, except as permitted by fair use provisions.

bottom of page