top of page
Search

The Joy of Figuring Shit Out

Writer: Matthew Dyet
Matthew Dyet
2 days ago
7 min read

Modern games have been having a crisis of trust with their players. Yellow paint (for its excessive hate) is a great example of how this often comes through in the way we make our games. Level designers are smart: players walk out onto a plateau, they see their destination on the horizon as a clear landmark. That tells players "navigate your way to that destination". Yellow paint removes a key part of the exercise for the player: figuring out how exactly to do it. It is shorthand for "look at me" or "this is the way you want to go" or "you can interact with this". Players don't really get the opportunity to figure out how to do things or what matters, because the journey has been finely crafted for them.


Game developers aren't lazy, but there's been a clear overreliance on yellow paint if players are now noticing it to feel that the game does not trust them to figure things out on their own. In the Door Problem, an essay by Liz England, she discusses the design of something as simple as a door: how do we communicate to a player if the door is openable, or if it is just set dressing? Game designers have come up with a lot of really clever solutions to that problem: using style of door (such as a push bar) to communicate purpose or usability, or using light (such as warm light in an otherwise cold game) to draw attention to important doors. Light belongs in the environment, so even a slightly different glow blends into the background.


Yellow paint removes the complexity of the problem entirely. Door is yellow? It can open. That's an over-dramatization of course, most games aren't making their doors yellow. But the point remains that its presence is often felt, and rarely feels earned. Explosive red barrels are ubiquitous and accepted, but yellow paint is not. I suspect the difference is that where a red barrel feels like set dressing, yellow paint exists to communicate something to the player directly - a feature environments rarely have. Few games have made their yellow paint feel earned in the setting, aside perhaps from Abiotic Factor thanks to the existence of IS-1057 in its universe: a paranormal yellow paint can that occasionally happens to have passed through an area ahead of you.


It's also just funny.


But the problem with yellow paint isn't its existence or the way it feels out of place. Instead, the problem is how it reduces an interesting interaction between a player and the game to noticing an out of place colour. I love the Uncharted games, but it's endlessly funny to me that the difference between a climbable surface and one that is not is whether a flock of birds have shat all over it to turn it white. Obviously that's an effort to make the guidance feel like it belongs, but why only the surfaces I'm meant to climb? In a way it removes some of my agency: I don't feel smart for finding the way around in Uncharted, I feel like the designer held my hand on a guided tour through the level.


Several games released in 2026 did a great job of highlighting the problem, but also the potential solution. On one side we have Insomniac's Wolverine, a game where players take on the role of the aforementioned gruff bisexual Canadian man, so I can understand why the designers may have wanted to hold the players hand. The excessive scent trail leads the designers provided seem out of place in a game very clearly crafted for an adult audience, if the excessive blood and violence the game contains is any indication of the intended audience. Rather than experiencing the world as Wolverine, players experience the world as Insomniac's Wolverine, led through neatly crafted cutscenes and setpieces that hamper the agency it feels that Wolverine should have. What started as well intended assistance was so obvious that it instead became a barrier.


In stark contrast to Wolverine is Queens Domain, which gives you a brief rundown of the setting and your objective, throws you on an island, and gets out of your way. There's some gentle tutorialising: go find this key to open this door, do a boss fight, understand the game loop. But every NPC that sends you on such a journey meets the same fate: death. So determined is Queens Domain to stay out of your way that everybody who could give you direction or explain the world even a little will inevitably end up dead, leaving you to figure it all out for yourself.


The closest Queen's Domain comes to giving you direction or clues is in the literature scattered around the world, and it's very easily missed. For all the challenges its combat presents (which gets progressively easier as you become stronger), the true challenge of Queens Domain is actually figuring out what you need to do and where you should go next. It's a game best played with an open notepad, and if you're anything like me, you will start to write down everything you see just in case it's important later.


I hadn't realised how refreshing this approach to design was until I reached for a guide early on. Certain weapons in Queens Domain 'evolve', becoming stronger variants with new abilities. In the early game looking at the store with my limited spending money, I reached for a guide to explain what sort of weapon would best suit, what's worth investing in? Immediately I learned about a key weapon in the game and spoiled myself on something I wouldn't run into until 40 hours into the experience. Such spoilers wouldn't typically bother me, but in hindsight I realised that I robbed myself of what Queens Domain does best: the opportunity to just figure it out on my own.


The game's crowning achievement for me is one I'm sure the handful of players who have engaged with its design in the same way felt the same sense of awe and "wow, that actually worked?" when it happened. I won't spoil it for you, but it genuinely was one of the coolest discoveries I've had second only to figuring out Tunic's Golden Path for myself, and there's vastly less setup required for it in Queens Domain. You just have to try something. For the designers there's a massive risk here: a lot of modern games have taught us to be passive observers, and in order to achieve the game's "true" ending you will need to experiment or reach for that guide. True to its 90s visual style, it's a game that is best played if you treat it like your dialup internet connection is at a premium.


But there are also points where this design breaks down. Queens Domain has a lot of collectibles, many essential to the true ending of the game. There's no tracker, no way of knowing which areas you've cleared, so I spent hours retreading old ground until it simply wasn't fun anymore. I reached for the guide, and found other players with the same problem who'd even built a tool to read save files for missing items. If yellow paint is intended to assist players to prevent frustration, this was my tipping point where I wished maybe the game had just a little. Getting lost isn't the problem: it adds wonder and scale to a world. The problem is the moment being lost turns into being frustrated about being lost.


Control Resonant is a gentler example of the approach taken by Queens Domain. It comes with a map and objective markers, but filtered through Remedy's signature weirdness: you're traversing what may as well be four dimensional space using a printout of blurry a satellite image. The map isn't entirely accurate, and that's the point: in the same way a warm light in a cool game has fuzzy edges, Resonant's map is similarly fuzzy and allows for player interpretation. It provides direction without removing the wonder of figuring out just how to reach a marker. In a game played on every surface, it's hard to imagine not providing some means of grounding the player and assisting their navigation. And so Resonant points to an area, not the route; the trailhead, not the path. A tracker for Queens Domain in its final hours would benefit from a similar design: narrow the search without resolving it, and the game loses none of its wonder.


The catch is that the tipping point where being lost leads to frustration is different for everyone. The adult happy to wander for hours and the adult with forty minutes on a Tuesday night after the kids are in bed are both hit with frustration, just at different times. Not everybody has the same appetite to work it out, be it navigating a world or a particularly challenging fight. The argument is to design for the player with limited time, but it's clear that doesn't satisfy the player who wants to try things on their own. For these games to reach a larger audience, we need to give them back their agency.


Giving players the agency to figure out the how on their own doesn't mean removing the guardrails, but offering the guardrails as an option for those players who would benefit. Shadow of the Tomb Raider did this exceptionally well, making its assistive paint part of its difficulty settings to allow players to tailor how much of the world they had to read for themselves. It's surprising that such an elegant solution hasn't become more popular, but the core reason could be the aforementioned Door Problem. To implement a toggle for paint requires a conversation about what communicates a climbable surface when the white paint is gone.


Designing games without assistance like this will require a change to how we choose to design our games. The level of assistance provided by default really needs to be tailored to the audience: a Dark Souls player is going to expect challenge. A Wolverine player may have expected more challenge than they got. Thee dial for just how much assistance is needed by default must allow more time for players to try and fail on their own. Any sort of in-game assistance needs to be an ever-present factor in every design conversation, and it needs to not be taken as a given: how does Wolverine play without its scent trails, or Uncharted without its bird shit cliffs? Allow the players the opportunity to discover and choose if they need more help than what comes in the box by default. The goal should never have been to stop players getting lost at all, but to trust them to decide for themselves when they've been lost long enough.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


WebsiteBookends_HeaderT.png
  • BlueskyPaddedWhite
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • ItchIoPaddedWhite
  • Instagram

© 2025 Matthew Dyet. All rights reserved.
The content, design, code, and graphics on GreatGames.dev are the intellectual property of Matthew Dyet and are protected under international copyright laws. No part of this website may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form without prior written permission, except as permitted by fair use provisions.

bottom of page